Food Review: Limited Edition Strawberry Banana Cheerios
Rating Fish Sandwiches - Where does Long John Silver's Rank? #fishsandwich

Rating Fish Sandwiches - Where does McDonald's rank?

By Mike Thayer

McDonald's Filet-O-Filet
Looks can be deceiving...

Eating fish sandwiches on a daily basis for lunch and dinner...  You know I'm doing this Challenge in the name of 'Food Science' (cough), right?  I'm eating through the bad and average sandwiches so you don't have to...

In 2018 I reviewed the fish sandwiches from national fast food chains but I figured it's time for a fish sandwich update.  I'll be reviewing all those restaurants again, as there's been some changes, some 'new and improved' sandwiches as well as new offerings.  But for this 2022 review, along with the fast food joints I'll be including fast casual chains as well as the local restaurants, making it a "Who makes the best fish sandwich in Wichita?" Challenge!

Today I traveled to McDonald's to pick up a Filet-O-Fish.  I wasn't looking forward to it because having a few of these in the past, I already know it's not going to be a great fish sandwich...  Again, done in the name of 'Food Science' (cough).

McDonald's ranked #7 back in the 2018 Fish Sandwich review, 7th place out of 9 restaurants sampled.

Here's the description from the McDonald's website:  Dive into our wild-caught Filet-O-Fish®! This McDonald’s fish sandwich has fish sourced from sustainably managed fisheries, on melty American cheese and topped with creamy McDonald’s tartar sauce, all served on a soft, steamed bun.

You get less tartar and less cheese on the 2022 fish sandwich

The steamed bun is nice, in fact it's probably the nicest thing about this sandwich.   This is a change from 2018 when the fish was served on a toasted bun.  Moving on...  Based on previous sampling, the Filet-O-Fish 'lived up' to expectations, as in being a less-than-stellar fish sandwich and on the bottom rungs of the fish sandwich ladder.  The breading on the processed fish didn't bring any crunch whatsoever, it's like they steamed the fish along with the bun.  The filet was under seasoned and the fish to bun ratio was off.  The creamy tartar is good although I didn't get tartar in every bite.  The cheese I can do without, I've never understood the McDonald's infatuation with putting a slice of cheese on a piece of fish.  About that cheese, is it an inflation thing or is McDonald's actually scaling back based on customer feedback?  That cheese slice has gotten smaller, for those of you who like that cheese on the fish, you don't get cheese in every bite, it doesn't cover the filet. 

Scoring 39 out of a possible 63 points and costing me $8.05 for a value meal to include fries and a drink, I'm giving the McDonald's Filet-O-Fish 3 out of 5 Bachelor on the Cheap stars.  This is a below average fish sandwich and is NOT worthy of a repeat buy.  Of the sandwiches sampled so far, this one has the lowest score.

3 stars


Poor fish to bun ratio, the filet should protrude from the bun on all sides
McDonald's Filet-O-Fish 2018
Image from 2018, the Filet-O-Fish was over dressed with tartar and check out the fish to bun ratio.

The McDonald's visited on this occasion is located at 1219 S Rock Rd, Wichita, KS 67207.  Hitting the drive through at about 11:30am, there were two cars ahead of me but service was friendly and pretty quick. After ordering, I received my Value Meal in about 3 minutes.

Related, posted in 2018: Who has the best fast food fish sandwich? They are listed here from worst to first

Related: A "Who makes the best fish sandwich in Wichita?" Challenge - Day 1 Lunch: Sonic (Sonic was not reviewed in 2018)

Related: A "Who makes the best fish sandwich in Wichita?" Challenge - Day 2 Lunch: Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers

Related: A "Who makes the best fish sandwich in Wichita?" Challenge - Day 3 Lunch: Louisiana Famous Fried Chicken

Related: A "Who makes the best fish sandwich in Wichita?" Challenge - Day 3 Dinner: Fish and More

Related: Burger King Fish Sandwich sucked in 2018, it still sucks in 2022

Related: How does Hardee's stack up in the Fish Sandwich Challenge?

Related: How does Arby's stack up in the Fish Sandwich Challenge?

Related: Krispy's Po' Boy Fish Sandwich is OUTSTANDING!

$pend Wisely My Friends...

Enjoy this post?

Buy Me a Coffee

If you appreciate the article you just read and want to support more great content on, you can help keep this site going with a one-time or a monthly donation.  Thank you so much for your support! ~ Mike

follow me on twitter @Bacheloronthe1

follow me on Pinterest

follow me on Instagram



Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)